Originally posted on http://digitaldiatribes.wordpress.com on March 15, 2007.
You can finally dispense with all the e-mails now. I’m about to finally give my opinions on this year’s season of “American Idol.” You people have been very impatient.
Before I critique the actual singers, let me put a few comments on the table. I am a musician. I am a singer. I am not, and have never been in the music industry, and therefore am just an everyday clod with an opinion.
From my admittedly limited experience on the stage, I can unequivocally state that all the people on American Idol are very good singers. What’s that, you say? Sanjaya is awful? Hey, not so fast here…
You see, we all heard the auditions. And then the judges heard everyone during Hollywood Week. These people can sing. However, just as a well-trained opera singer would sound awful singing a Diana Ross song, what happens is that these people with very good voices just may not be able to translate an otherwise good voice to a pop stage. It doesn’t mean they are terrible singers, but it may mean they are terrible in that setting, in which case they are not cut out to be the American Idol.
The other reason I point this out is because the judges and us are really overly critical of generally good performances. The nature of the show is to set the bar high, and it is what it is. But just because not everyone is Kelly Clarkson or Fantasia or Clay or Melinda doesn’t make them terrible. This is live performance, for crying out loud. As a case in point, I dare you to say with a straight face that the majority of guests that they have had – generally legends in the industry – ever outperform more than a handful of the idol contestants. They don’t. If you were listening to Diana Ross or Kenny Rogers or Donna Summer on this show for the first time, and thought they were a contestant, you’d wonder what the judges had been smoking when they decided to put them through to the final 24.
Finally, but connected with the idea above, if anyone has ever sung on stage you will know that there are times where you can’t hear everything as perfectly as you’d like. Whether it’s your own voice or the instruments, not hearing the right mix can send you off-key, and it can be hard to recover.
I felt that backdrop is important. Because now I move to critiquing the contestants in the context of them competing to be a star.
The final twelve consists of six men and six women. Let’s be honest. The men just don’t cut it this year, relative to the talent in the female pool. A couple guys could make it as an artist, I think, but just don’t jump out as that one star that is head and shoulders above the others.
We’ll start with Brandon, the first of the Final Twelve to get booted. What was he thinking? The guy wasn’t phenomenal, but he could sing. But nothing about the song “Can’t Hurry Love” is a good vocal choice for even the best singer. He has himself to blame for the song choice. Now, that said, Diana Ross music night is a disaster for any number of contestants. I know the show has always done it, and I guess people like it, but if they are seriously trying to find America’s favorite new pop star, why are we presented to two hours of music from 30-40 years ago, in a music style that nobody listens to any more, in music styles that eight of the twelve participants would never, ever do? It really makes no sense, but again, it is what it is.
Next to go should be Sanjaya. OK, enough of the hula-hooping, exotic hair, and female persona. I’m not being mean here, just honest. It’s grating. That all aside, he is simply not cut out for the big stage and pop performance. He just isn’t.
I can’t figure out why Phil keeps getting beat up a bit. Of all the guys, I put him as the best vocalist. Maybe he just doesn’t have the appearance? Don’t know. I’m a guy who doesn’t typically pay attention to those things, unless it’s someone with exotic hair and earing dancing like a girl, but isn’t a girl.
Chris Sligh – good vocalist. But it’s just goofy watching him on stage. If I close my eyes, I’m with it. Then I open it to see some really big guy with poofy hair singing “Endlesslove” twice as fast as it should go, and I lose the connection.
Blake – definitely cool with the whole voice-percussion talent. And he really can sing. Not my style, but I appreciate it.
The other Chris. Do you guys get it? Seriously? I don’t. I’ve seen seizures that appear more comfortable than his on-stage twitches, which I think are supposed to be “moves” of some sort. And vocally – average at best.
So those are the guys. A couple deserve to go a ways, but none deserve to be the next Idol.
As for the women, it should be a couple weeks before any are at risk, but I guess you never know.
Haley: Wendy really likes her, but I don’t see much there. A good, nice vocalist, but if not the weakest of the bunch, she’s right there.
Stephanie: Similar to Haley. Just not all that memorable, but a real solid singer. Actually, all the women are really solid singers, so at this point you nitpick reasons why they should go. Steph should go because her style is similar to 2-3 others who are better than her. At the very least, this would bring some diversity. In this respect, she should probably go before Haley.
Gina – OK, I’m not a big fan of dyed hair, and if my daughter ever comes home with a pierced tongue, I’m going to punch a hole in the wall. But she can actually sing. Not in the top tier, but of all the contestants she is closest to the music I enjoy, and she does a nice job. It at least adds a different flavor, and she should stick around a bit longer.
Jordin – I like Jordin. Seventeen years old and a killer voice. It bugs me a little that she gets left out of a lot of the discussion, because in her own way she’s as good as the other two that get discussed (Lakisha and Melinda). L and M sing in a certain genre, but truth be told, Jordin is probably the best vocalist in the actual pop genre. She deserves to make the final three if not the final two.
Lakisha and Melinda – let’s just lump these two together. You watch them both and they are just natural. It comes easy. Both are awesome. Both are similar in style. Lakisha probably has the bigger voice of the two, but I give the nod to Melinda for personality and stage presence in addition to that vocal.
Now, some final thoughts: Did anyone else smell hypocrisy this week? OK, so I wasn’t necessarily crazy about Blake’s arrangement or Chris’s arrangement of the music, but come on… How many times have we heard comments like “You didn’t do anything to make that song your own.” So, a couple guys decide to take a song and make it their own, and they get hammered on because they messed with classics. Make up your mind already. Not to mention, Chris’s review was all about the arrangement of the song, with nary a comment on the vocal. Isn’t Simon always lamenting with the words “This is a singing competition”? Critiquing the arrangement is fair game, but at least tell the guy what you thought about the actual performance.
Finally, a comment on the voting. I’m a math guy, so maybe the results aren’t as big a surprise to me, but think about it for a moment, and it makes sense why the “wrong” person is voted out occasionally. The reason is because we don’t vote anyone out. We vote to keep people in. I guarantee that if America were asked to vote against people instead of for people, the worst people would more consistently get booted. Now, I’m not saying that makes more sense, because in the end the order doesn’t really matter all that much and the final three are usually who they should be. There just may be some bumps in the road getting there. But just keep in mind when Sanjaya stays, that it’s because he’s got a bunch of 16 year old girls voting to keep him around for some reason. If we were asked to vote against him, all the rest of us would. Different methods – different results. It sorts itself out as the field dwindles.
By the way, I’m not a voter. I think I’ve maybe felt compelled to call a couple times. I just like to watch and critique.
Thank goodness there are enough people with enough spare time on their hands who actually care enough to vote, so I have something to keep watching.